Blogging is more of a mirror than a reflection (aka high school ended a long time ago)
I want to clarify that this particular post isn’t directed toward anyone specifically, nor is it meant to imply that I am either ‘hot shit’, ‘warm shit’, an ‘authority’ or ‘awesome’. After reading Angie‘s post and Meredith‘s, my brain just had words. Evidently, a lot of them
PS. I am ‘awesome’ (ironic quotes intended).
Okay, so high school. Everyone’s experience was different, even if you were a nerd in the corner of the caf, with a tray barely weighed down by food, listening to Tori Amos on your Discman, just like that other woman you know who did that, too! Social media/blogging is also different for everyone – their experience, their ‘success’, their presumed ‘success’ and everything outside and in between.
The two venues are not inter-changable for one simple fact: you choose whether you participate in social media or not. High school, for most, is kind of a mandatory thing – at least to a certain level. Then drop out, feel free.
I did. Twice.
Anyway.
Here’s one thing that they have in common, but I’m pretty fucking tired of hearing about it (I never proposed to be eloquent): if your self-esteem is what determines your experience, your experience is likely to suck.
If comment numbers determine whether you care enough to write, because, holy fuck, you are a writer, then a) you’re normal and b) it’s not going to get better if you regularly start to get more.
If whether the ‘popular kids’ retweet you, or anyone at all, determines how many conversations you feel relevant enough to start or participate in, then I hope that you have the ability to put that notion away when it comes time to speak up about things that matter to you. And if you don’t? You’re a) normal and b) the only one holding yourself back.
Here’s the thing, and people who I’ve read embittered posts from about this subject and their victimization because of it (again, please see disclaimer above) tend to argue its possibility: the ‘popular kids’ are just like everyone else. They may have more exposure or traffic or retweets or followers. They may have poignant posts that result in millions of comments ranging between “I love you” and “This made me cry” and “I wish I could write like this”, but they are also nervous about hitting publish.
The ‘popular kids’ will reread their posts for errors, unfunny jokes, a trace of something they feel proud of. They’ll read their comments – whether they respond personally to every single one (or any). They will be aware of the reactions their words have brought about and it will matter to them.
How you feel about those people not replying back to your comment or tweet or Facebook Like is, from my experience, you judging yourself as unworthy and seeing self-fulfilling prophecy where you seek it out. I know this part because I’ve been there. I know this is universal because those ‘popular kids’ have been there, too.
This year marks my seventh year blogging. I’m, by no means – in my own eyes, or really any one else’s – popular. But you know what? Fuck being popular. Quinn may be fucking annoying every week on Glee, bemoaning how frightened she is, but her point is sound (if not merely fictional): being popular and looked up to? Begets expectation.
Those ‘popular kids’ who aren’t acknowledging presences are instantaneously thrust into a valley made of snotty names said under the breaths of some (unquantifiable) mass of people. They’re snobs, elitist and just plain too good to _____.
But you know? They’re not. They’re busy, just like you are.
They have soccer and piano practices to drive to, after getting their oil changed and prepping dinner. They have to help with homework. They have to wash the underwear of every non-effective ass-wiper in their home. Just like you do, too. They don’t have the time, necessarily, to jump into their WordPress dashboard and ensure that each and every comment they’ve received is replied to, lest someone feel targeted with silence. They don’t have time to RT everything that shows up in their Twitter stream, because, quite frankly, they’re doing stuff like Tide Bleach Penning another blood stain out of the knee of their hyperactive (but rad) daughter’s white tights.
And stuff does not allow for them to read all of the blog posts that have been auto-tweeted, comment on them, digg them, email you, tweet you, RT your funny 130-character synopsis of New Moon, or frankly, shave their armpits. Because when you’re a ‘popular kid’, it’s quite easy to follow 270000 people on Twitter and have you ever tried to even READ, never mind act upon 270000 people’s average one to sixty daily tweets?
You couldn’t do it. And they’re no superhero, either.
With more money comes more spending. With more readership comes more friendships. Define those how you will. You’re no richer, if you’re still spending proportionately to what you used to at your old income, and you don’t get more hours in the day, just because you have more relationships in social media.
So here’s what the embittered posts argue, but it seems to need repeating (frequently), so I’ll restate it: the cool kids aren’t ignoring you (most of them, anyway) (I assume) (But I guess some are and hey, who wants them, if they are?). The cool kids? Really don’t think they’re cool kids.
The cool kids I’ve known are the people who hide in bathrooms and hope people will talk to them there, because they’re too anxious to be in the crowded room.
The cool kids I’ve known denigrate themselves, for an apparent lack of popularity, traffic, comment numbers and/or relevance.
The cool kids I’ve known see their stats and go Ugh, just like embittered people may, and it doesn’t matter that someone else would fist pump multiple times for the same Ugh-inducing Analytics report.
The cool kids I’ve known? Are cool because they’re people I’ve enjoyed knowing. They’re humble and valid and insecure and will talk at great lengths about a post they read that made them think or feel something in particular — and 99% of the time, that post they’re talking about isn’t written by another of the awesome posse. It’s not an inner-clique member. It’s a post they came across, because someone with more time – for the tweeting or the Digging or the Facebook Liking – shared it.
These people don’t feel like they’re popular, just like you might. And they also wonder why so-and-so didn’t say something back to them. These people are (again, in general) nearly completely oblivious to any coveting of their attentions. These people?
Are just like you and me and her and so on.
I’ve been lucky to be friends with some of these kids because they were them, not because it meant anything specific about my success. And I remember my reaction after someone that I used to be friends with told me that I may be looked at as a name-dropper because of who I was publicly friends with.
I stopped using my friends’ names. I stopped tweeting their posts and linking them. I made our conversations and that’s-what-he-said jokes happen in the background. I was afraid of being judged as a lessor-than, attempting to get in the good graces of the head cheerleader.
I even kind of drew away from some of them, lest I be looked at as the chick who screws all of the football team for popularity, who ends up only being known as the chick who screwed the whole football team. And gave them syphilis.
I don’t have syphilis. It’s a metaphor.
I’m not sure what for, though.
So. I’ve been blogging for coming up on seven years. In terms of popularity, let’s just say that I’m equal to the person who may one day earn her PhD, but first needs some high school courses, and then college and her master’s – and she’s doing it one course per semester. At this rate, if I’m to achieve popularity, I’m looking at being really well-known by the age of 83.
I’ve blogged about everything – the usual mom shit, the unusual mom shit, the crazy shit, the ex boyfriend shit, the abuse shit, the happiness shit not-shit. I’ve been naked both metaphorically and literally and I’ve wondered why I wasn’t ever asked to be in any damn eating disorder calendar (I say that with love, really).
I’ve also blogged professionally for coming up on five years – again, about the crazy and mom shit, and abuse and happiness. And other bullshit and other lightness. I’ve worked with some clients who weren’t anyone in the ever-changing immeasurable ruler of mommy-blogger popularity, but who had so much optimism and ego, I figured they must have at least a ten-incher in their pants; I’ve worked with clients who were absolutely fucking amazing in their growth, content, numbers, intentions and follow-through, who felt that they weren’t worthy of some of the popular kids’ acknowledgement. They were popular kids, by anyone else’s definition.
See? Oblivious.
And I’ve, on a personal level, had amazing feedback, zero trollism, and made money while doing it, and have been called relevant and popular and a known presence by those fucking amazing people (who I assume are working with something much more manageable in their pants, like eight inches). I’ve also been asked to speak on various conference panels, have been written up and questioned for a few magazines and papers, and have been an interviewee on CBC.
Just so you know how impressive that is: this blog has, thus far, earned 2278 page views in the past 30 days. A month’s traffic for me lately is a piss-poor day to another’s. It’s a maybe I should just quit moment, to a seasoned veteran that you may consider epic. My highest traffic has been somewhere around 12K in a month. That’s three days, to someone I consider fucking fabulous, who considers themself lazy and under-whelming.
The universal truth is simple.
Blogging, social media, whatever the definition now encompasses, and especially in the frame of mommy-relatedness, is not like high school.
It’s like life. You know this.
You know that that other mom, who brought three dozen perfectly-iced cupcakes to the end-of-year preschool potluck may be surrounded by cupcake-adoring fans and that you’re there, with your Tollhouse cookies, feeling like you suck. What you might not know is that that mom feels like she should have used a better chocolate for the ganache and she’s worried that people will try it and know that she’s a poseur.
You know that that woman on the street, waiting for the light to change, is fabulously attired, down to the current season’s Manolos, and you’re in Chucks and cut-offs, so you find yourself looking down, self-consciously, hoping to shrink away from public scrutiny. But you might not know that this woman’s dressed like a ten because she’s pretty sure her husband’s seeing an eleven that’s a decade younger than she is.
You know that the three-child, six-figure earning family who has time for lessons, practices, church, volunteering and throwing a party every season – often featuring the best burgers ever to be BBQed, since man first put beef to flame – has it all together, while you’re struggling to pay off the new water heater and your kids have just eaten KD. Again. Today. You don’t know that the husband grew up in poverty, with abusive, addicted parents and does everything he can to not allow his family to face the same reality – even if it means that he’s got major ownership in a adult film production company, because it brings in the extra money that he worries will never be enough.
Every one’s experience is different, but, excepting the rarities, everyone’s is also the same.
Everyone’s got doubts, fears, intimacy, daddy and abandonment issues. Everyone worries that they’re not good enough. Everyone uses some measure, usually involving numbers – whether in terms of income, followers or shoe price – to determine their worth.
And we do it to everyone else, too.
So when you’re feeling like blogging or Tweeting or Becoming A Fan Of is just like high school, consider this: if it is? So’s everything else.
